A must read

When We See You Again
Rachel Goldberg-Polin
New York: Random House, 2026, 266 pages

What a gift author Rachel Goldberg-Polin, a Chicago native and educator living in Jerusalem bestowed on us – her heart-wrenching as well as heart-warming account of the unique bond with her 23-year-old son, Hersh, who was murdered in a Gaza tunnel by Hamas terrorists on his 328th day of captivity following the October 7, 2023, most vicious massacres. With him were executed Ori, Almog, Alex, Eden, and Carmel after enduring untold torture and excruciating suffering. Travel-loving, curious, artistic, and musically inclined Hersh had a ticket for a much-anticipated trip to India, following an Israeli post-military service tradition to go abroad.

This book is a sacred and searing intimate sharing of a bereaved mother’s yearning to contend with the enormity of her loss. As an Orthodox Jew she is reassured that upon death she would reunite with Hersh, reflected in the book’s title, When We See You Again. Her sustaining faith is anchored to inflicted Job’s succinct response to his overwhelming anguish with four powerful words, “God gives, God takes,” describing it movingly, “For me the most profound, impactful statement in This World comes from the Hebrew Bible itself.” And yet tenaciously, a deeply wounded mother struggles to accept her heart-breaking loss of tragic separation from an enchanting, beloved son.

In her unique writing style, both prosaic and poetic with a healthy dose of humor, the author succeeds in creating an essential guide to bereaved parents and all humans who will find a measure of consolation and strength through her heroic journey to come to grips with the unfathomable loss of a promising young life so cruelly cut short. Particularly touching that Hersh, the eldest child in his family with two younger sisters, was named after Hershey’s chocolate. Indeed, he was sweet and caring to all. At age 13 he was involved in helping Eritrean refugees in Israel and often recalled his relatives who perished in the Holocaust. In Gaza’s painful captivity he found deep support quoting renowned Austrian Holocaust survivor and founder of Logotherapy, Victor Frankl’s classic, Man’s Search for Meaning, which he shared in the tunnel to strengthen his co-captives, challenging them with the book’s famous remedy of finding a “Why” in trying circumstances.

Hersh and his parents’ dual Israeli and American citizenship failed to protect his life while the dedicated parents traversed the world meeting with statesmen and celebrities to no avail. However, this special family has touched millions globally with Hersh turning into an iconic figure, hopefully assisting in transforming an anguished humanity from tomorrow’s blight and hate of the other.

Hersh’s memory and that of all the innocent victims in the worst day since Israel’s 1948 founding is an abiding blessing! The must-read of a both shattering and reviving work of intricate art with a rare outpouring of an amazing soul concludes with a message of eternal hope, “I will see you again, Hersh. I will. Do you hear me? I will it. Nothing will have changed, but my love for you will be even greater than it is now, or now, or now, or now. My love will be spilling forth from my cup overflowing, as it says in Psalm 23, all over my hand holding it. My goopy love, gushing all over the ground.”