Israel on Trial with Judge Roy Altman
Thursday, December 10, 7 pm, Sandler Family Campus
Anyone who believes Americans have already made up their minds about Israel should spend an hour with Judge Roy Altman. At the recent Jewish Federations of North America General Assembly, Altman took the stage and quickly had the room laughing, leaning in, and listening closely.
“I was captivated by Judge Altman,” Mona Flax, United Jewish Federation of Tidewater’s president says. “He is brilliant and incredibly quick, with a fearlessness in the way he makes the case for Israel that is hard to miss. I walked out thinking the same thing I imagine many people in that room did: our community needs to hear him.”
Since October 7, 2023, the federal judge has traveled to almost all 50 states and spoken on more than 65 college and law school campuses, along with countless schools, churches, and community gatherings far outside the Jewish world.
And after all that travel, Altman rejects the increasingly common conclusion that social media has won, young people have made up their minds, and no one is listening anymore.
“That is nonsense. That is absolute nonsense.”
At Duke University, a Jewish freshman told Altman about friends who wished her Shana Tova and Shabbat Shalom. She knew they did not hate Jews.
But what those same friends posted about Israel was another matter.
She was afraid to tell them how she felt about Israel because she worried they might no longer want to be her friends. Altman told her that in 10 years, she probably would not even remember many of the people she was trying so hard not to offend freshman year. “You shouldn’t expect people to love a hologram you’ve created for them,” he said.
It was one college student’s story, but Altman’s challenge was much bigger: How often are Jews staying silent because speaking up feels uncomfortable? He understands why. No one wants to lose a friend or wreck Thanksgiving dinner. But after crisscrossing America, Altman has reached a hopeful conclusion: the loudest voices are not necessarily representative of everyone else. There are people who know very little about Israel and are willing to listen when someone is willing to talk to them.
He challenged the audience: “Tell the truth and be proud of the truth.”
That may be what makes Altman so compelling. He is deeply concerned about this moment but refuses to be defeated by it. He has been making the case for Israel across America. And people are listening. On December 10, Tidewater gets its chance. This is one conversation worth showing up for.
Free and open to the community. RSVP required: www.JewishVA.org/IsraelToday. Enhanced security measures will be in place. Plan to arrive early to allow extra time for security and check-in.
Presented by the Lee & Bernard Jaffe Family Jewish Book Festival in partnership with the Jewish Community Relations Council of United Jewish Federation of Tidewater, Simon Family JCC, all area synagogues, and Community Partners’ 16th Annual Israel Today Series.

